Opinion

Taleb Rifai vs Zurab Pololikashvil: Heavyweight vs Lightweight


Heavyweights vs lightweights qualified vs unqualified, it is never too hard to spot. We all can understand anyone reaching for a position one is not qualified to perform in. But not if the world’s largest single industry is placed at risk.

The Outgoing UNWTO Secretary-General And The Proposed Incoming Secretary-General Elect:
Perhaps if one owns a football club, one can take a chance on hiring an individual with zero professional football club management. As was the case with Zurab Pololikashvili, who had a brief stint at a football club, as part of his chequered past.  None of which qualifies him to rather audaciously reach, and it truly is a reach, to lead our United Nations World Tourism Organization (UNWTO).

Is it appropriate for the General Assembly in Chengdu, China to vote into power a novice to global tourism’s top post, a neophyte with almost no tourism experience? 
This is our UNWTO, the respected and esteemed organization that represents the world’s largest single industry. Let’s press the pause button and consider the qualifications of the individual who will either be ratified or rejected at the upcoming 22nd UNWTO General Assembly as the new Secretary-General.

Let’s review two resumes. First the widely admired, well respected, Taleb Rifai.

As UNWTO’s outgoing Secretary-General he has an extraordinary track record and proven stellar leadership with very strong, able hands. This is is  Dr.Rifai’s CV when he was a candidate for the position of UNWTO Secretary General.
  • Mr. Taleb Rifai assumed the functions of Secretary General ad interim of the World  Tourism Organization (UNWTO) since 1st. March. He served as Deputy Secretary General from February 2006 to February 2009
  • Prior to assuming his current post, he was the Assistant Director of the International Labor Organization (ILO) for three consecutive years. His responsibilities included the overall supervision and implementation of the International Labour Standards, as well as advising on labour markets and employments policies, particularly in the Middle East region.
  • From 1999 to 2003, Mr. Rifai served in several ministerial portfolios in the Government of Jordan, first as Minister of Planning and International Cooperation in charge of Jordan’s Development Agenda and bilateral and multilateral relationships with donor countries and agencies. He was later appointed Minister of Information, in which capacity he was in charge of communication and public media and restructured the Jordan Television Network. In 2001, his portfolio was expanded to include the Ministry of Tourism and Antiquity.
  • During his term as Minister of Tourism and Antiquity, Mr. Rifai established Jordan’s first Archaeological Park in the ancient city of Petra in collaboration with UNESCO and the World Bank. He also realized several grand projects in Jerash, the Dead Sea and Wadi Rum. As Minister of Tourism, he was also the Chairman of the Jordan Tourism Board, President of the Ammon School for Tourism and Hospitality and was elected Chairman of the Executive Council of the UNWTO in 2001
  • In the three years preceding his service in the Jordanian Cabinet, Mr. Rifai was the CEO of Jordan’s Cement Company, one of the country’s largest public shareholdings companies with over 4000 employees. During his term he successfully lead and directed the first large scale privatization and restructuring scheme in Jordan by bringing in the French cement company Lafarge in 1998 and continued to serve as CEO under the new Lararge management.
  • From 1993 to 1997, Mr. Rifai was actively involved in policy marking and developing trade and investment strategies, initially in his capacity as Director of Jordan’s Economic Mission to Washington DC promoting trade, investment and economic relations between Jordan and the USA. In 1995 he became the Director General of the newly established Investment Promotion Corporation, responsible for developing and implementing policies aiming at attracting Foreign Direct Investment into Jordan.
  • From 1973 to 1993 Mr.Rifai was involved in research, teaching and practicing Architecture and Urban Design in Jordan and the United States. He was a professor of Architecture at the University of Jordan and taught several courses in Philadelphia, Chicago and Cambridge. As an architect, he won several international competitions and supervised numerous projects, particularly in the rehabilitation of old urban centers.
  • Mr. Rifai received his PhD in Urban Design and Regional Planning from the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia in 1983, his Master’s degree in Engineering and Architecture from the Illinois Institute of Technology (IIT) in Chicago in 1979, and his BSc in Architectural Engineering from the University of Cairo in Egypt in 1983
  • Mr. Rifai, a Jordanian national born in 1949, has travelled and lectured extensively, and received several distinguished decorations including one of Jordan’s highest medals for public service, Al Kawkab, as well as several high-level decorations from France, Italy and other countries.EXPERIENCE and skills
  • Mr. Rifai’s background combines solid political experience and technical knowledge in the field of tourism, as well as experience in the work and functioning of International Organizations. His background also provides him with extensive economic, business and academic experience.
  • Throughout his professional career, Mr. Rifai has been a reformer and a consensus builder: Two important qualities in effecting sustainable change. His ability to introduce fresh thinking and to work closely with people in order to ensure buy-in and to achieve enduring reforms is evident in all his endeavours, notably, restructuring the Jordan Television Network, privatizing the Jordan Cement Company and introducing fresh thinking to the UNWTO
  • Having served as Deputy Secretary General of the UNWTO for the last three years, Mr. Rifai has acquired valuable experience and insight regarding the needs and prospects of the UNWTO. He is considering a strong candidate who possesses all the necessary skills, experience and knowledge as well as the capability to introduce much-needed reforms and changes at the UNWTO
Now let’s review Secretary-General Elect, Zurab Pololikashvili’s current resume, which does not reflect much experience within travel or tourism.
A bean counter, a money man, and a former football executive, Pololikashvili is not in the same league as Rifai, by any standards.  The emperor has no clothes it appears.
  • Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of Georgia to the Kingdom of Spain, the Principality of Andorra, the People’s Democratic Republic of Algeria and the Kingdom of Morocco Permanent Representative of Georgia to the World Tourism Organization (UNWTO)
  • Ambassador POLOLIKASHVILI has broad experience of working in both private and public sectors at high-profile positions.
  • He has extensive diplomatic experience, having represented Georgia to the World Tourism Organization (UNWTO), as well as serving as Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary to the Kingdom of Spain.
  • He also held a position of the Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs from 2005 to 2006.
  • 2009-2010, Minister of Economic Development of Georgia. As Minister of Economic Development of Georgia, Ambassador Pololikashvili was responsible for overseeing the country’s long-term fiscal growth strategies, for advancing foreign trade and investment policy initiatives, as well as for promoting the development of tourism, infrastructure and transportation sectors.
  • He was instrumental in launching an innovative policy for the development of tourism in Georgia, prioritizing the sphere on both the government and private sector agendas.
  • During Ambassador Pololikashvili’s tenure as the Minister of Economic Development, through key policy reforms, marketing activities, improvement of infrastructure and visa liberalization initiatives, Georgia managed to nearly double the annual number of international arrivals, from 1.5 million ( in 2009) to exceeding the 2.8 million mark by 2011.
  • Those reforms paved the way for sustainable tourism practices in Georgia and poverty alleviation initiatives, placing Georgia among top tourist destinations in the region. Minister Pololikashvili successfully led the economic liberalization processes, introducing more supportive policies for SMEs, and incentive programs to attract foreign investment for development of hard and soft infrastructure.
  • 2006 – 2009 Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of Georgia to the Kingdom of Spain.
  • 2005 – 2006 Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs of Georgia. In this capacity as Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs of Georgia, he supervised the departments for administrative, budgetary, financial and consular affairs, as well as the Department for Human Resources Management.
  • Pololikashvili was responsible for ushering in a new phase of more liberal and secure visa regimes, facilitation of processes to ease border crossing procedures, and deepening relations with various international organizations, including the UNWTO.
  • Experience private sector. Ambassador Pololikashvili’s private sector experience includes several years in the financial and banking sectors, serving as the Manager of International Operations for TBC Bank ( one of the most successful banks in Georgia), Director of TBC Bank’s Central Branch Office (2001-2005) and the Vice President of TBC Group (2010 – 2011) In 2001 – 2011
  • Ambassador Pololikashvili was CEO of FC Dinamo Tbilisi, the leading professional football team in Georgia. Academic Qualifications. 2008 – 2009 Global Senior Management Program (GSMP), IE Business School, Instituto de Empresa, Madrid, Spain 1994 – 1998
  • Bachelor’s Degree in Banking, Georgian Technical University, Tbilisi, Georgia.
  • Personal Data Date of birth: 12 January 1977, Tbilisi, Georgia Marital status: Married and has three children
  • Languages: Georgian (native) English, Spanish, and Russian (fluent) French, Japanese and Polish (spoken)
We believe our UNWTO deserves to managed, led and guided by an authentically seasoned tourism veteran, if not star. An individual widely recognized by our industry as being enormously capable of taking the reigns of our UNWTO.
As an industry, with choppy waters and widespread global unrest, we are depending on the upcoming General Assembly to not simply ratify the proposed Secretary-General Elect. One cannot fake or fudge knowledge, talent or authentic leadership.
The waters right now are more than murky for the General Assembly in Chengdu, China next month.
 The presentation of Pololikashvili as Secretary-General Elect is not alone enough to warrant ratification by voting nations.  We urge the voting General Assembly to take a long, hard look at the role of UNWTO Secretary-General. It is important, it is critical.  We need and demand a leader of our UNWTO who will have the vision, intelligence, ability, knowledge, experience, strength, and courage to lead and guide us collectively as an industry.
We’re depending on it.
Opinion

From Banker & Football Club Executive To Tourism’s Top Post?

Why would or should any individual without or very little tourism experience be appointed to head and lead the World Tourism Organization? (UNWTO)

It ordinarily takes a large amount of experience, talent, and industry recognition to become a candidate for global tourism’s top job, Secretary-General of the UNWTO.

Last May in Madrid, the UNWTO Executive Council, in the first round of the Secretary-General ballot process, gave 3 votes to Mr. Jaime Alberto Cabal (Colombia), 7 votes to Ms. Young-shim Dho (Republic of Korea), 4 votes to Mr. Márcio Favilla (Brazil), 11 votes to Mr. Walter Mzembi (Zimbabwe) and 8 votes to Mr.Zurab Pololikashvili (Georgia).

As none of the candidates received the “required majority” of votes on the first ballot, a second ballot was held. The second ballot gave 15 votes to Mr. Walter Mzembi and 18 votes to Mr. Zurab Pololikashvili.

With Pololikashvili being named the Secretary-General Elect, he now needs to receive 2/3 of the vote from the upcoming General Assembly in Chengdu, China to take office. Or put in a more reassuring way, only slightly more than 1/3 of the General Assembly has to vote no to the former football club executive as our Secretary-General.

As an industry, we should all be concerned, if not alarmed, at how the UNWTO electoral system appears to have failed us. It appears to be a system that is flawed, with outgoing, highly respected Secretary-General, Taleb Rifai, grappling with election results many do not understand.

While the election voting in Madrid is long over, there is growing hope any misdemeanors can be corrected at the upcoming General Assembly. It is not a done deal that Pololikashvili, who from his CV appears to somewhat of a job hopper, if not dilettante with his career choices, will actually win tourism’s top position.

It takes a skilled, seasoned industry leader, such as Dr. Rifai to navigate the UNWTO through choppy election waters with a complex system to work with. All eyes will be on Chengdu, China, to see if the world’s largest single industry is going to be saddled with a new leader with very little gravitas to perform intelligently in this important role.

Vote responsibly, vote intelligently!

Our industry will be at risk if we have a novice taking the reins of our UNWTO. This is an important position, with no room for an internship of the critical Secretary-General role or indeed, backroom deals to be permitted to determine the outcome.

The election we trust will be steered straight under the watchful stewardship of outgoing Secretary General, Dr. Taleb Rafai, we as an industry are depending on it.

News

Ambassador of Senegal presents credentials to World Tourism Organization (UNWTO)

The Ambassador of Senegal, H.E. Mr Mamadou Sow, has presented his credentials to the Secretary-General of the World Tourism Organization (UNWTO), Taleb Rifai, accrediting him as Permanent Representative of his country to UNWTO. UNWTO is the United Nations specialized agency for tourism and is based in Madrid, Spain.

During the meeting, Rifai expressed to Ambassador Sow the Organization’s determination and commitment to continue strengthening its close relationship with Senegal.

Senegal received 1 million international tourist arrivals in 2015; a plus of 4.5%, generating 368 million US dollars in receipts. Senegal has been a Member State of the UNWTO since 1975.

News

Ambassador of Yemen presents credentials to World Tourism Organization (UNWTO)

The Ambassador of Yemen, H.E. Mr Nabil Khalid Hassan Maisery, has presented his credentials to the Secretary-General of the World Tourism Organization (UNWTO), Taleb Rifai, accrediting him as Permanent Representative of his country to UNWTO. UNWTO is the United Nations specialized agency for tourism and is based in Madrid, Spain.

During the meeting, Rifai expressed to Ambassador Maisery the Organization’s determination and commitment to continue strengthening its close relationship with Yemen.

Yemen has been a Member State of the UNWTO since 1977.

Opinion

Georgia puts double pressure on China CNTA Chairman Li Jinzao

Countdown To The 22nd UNWTO General Assembly, Chengdu, China and the Secretary General Election Confirmation: 14 Days To Go.
China, as the world’s fourth most visited country and with a massive outbound market that every tourism board in the world hopes to capture market share of, our industry is very much looking forward to the 22nd UNWTO General Assembly (United Nations World Tourism Organization), starting September 11, 2017 in Chengdu, China.  
 

“China’s importance as a driver of tourism development cannot be understated. It is not only the world’s fourth most visited country, but the number one source market in the world, as well as a prominent leader in domestic tourism.

These numbers, alongside the Chinese authorities continued recognition of tourism as a strategic pillar of the national economy and an effective development tool, make China a fitting host for the next UNWTO General Assembly“, said UNWTO Secretary-General Taleb Rifai.

One of top priorities at the 22nd General Assembly meeting is voting for the new Secretary General of our UNWTO.  Highly placed, impeccable sources, have indicated Secretary-General Elect, Zurab Pololikashvili, has already made an advance, last ditch trip/mission to China, to garner support from the host country and neighboring nations.  

Needing two-thirds of the voting General Assembly to be ratified as the new Secretary General of  UNWTO, sources claim the Candidate Elect from Georgia and, critically, his government, is again engaged in election meddling.  This is tourism’s top post, we trust integrity and ethics will prevail within the voting community.  We all have to trust that, or all is lost.
From independent, reasonable, credible and documented accounts,  it was a combination of backroom meetings and secret handshake deals that garnered Polalikashvili the 18 Executive Council votes required to be presented before the General Assembly in Chengdu for final voting.  
 
Well placed sources have expressed concern the Candidate Elect, who did not show up at a single sanctioned UNWTO event during the campaigning process for the Secretary-General post, can take and find the time to travel to China ahead of this all-important General Assembly.

A July 24 twitter post by “Georgia in Spain” shows Georgian UNWTO nominee Ambassador Zurab Polalikashvili posting with Mr. Li Jinzao, CNTA Chairman shaking hands in front of the China National Tourist Authority in Beijing. The Georgian nominee proudly wrote, he is expecting full support by China in his confirmation vote in Chengdu.

It is expected to have Georgian Prime Minister  Giorgi Kvirikashvili attend the UNWTO General Assembly. 
This puts double pressure now on the Chinese Government and Mr. Li Jinzao to be bullied into a decision of support for Zurab Polalikashvili
This China meeting may have been a critical diplomatic move with far-reaching effects for tourism and travel on a global scale. This is not to be underestimated.  
However, we have every confidence UNWTO General Assembly voting members will not be influenced by outside interference. We have every confidence host country, China, will welcome all delegates fairly, warmly and very graciously.
Chengdu, China is show time for our UNWTO and the world’s largest single industry will be watching very closely.
Please check back for updates and breaking news as we countdown to the 22nd Assembly of the UNWTO in Chengdu, China.  Comments?
Please send us a note, we welcome feedback, on or off the record.
Opinion

UNWTO Secretary-General criticized WorldTourismWire at packed Madrid Ambassador meeting

At yesterdays UNWTO Ambassador meeting in Madrid, ahead of the General Assembly next month in China, the outgoing Secretary General, Dr. Taleb Rifai, chose to make curiously timed, critical remarks about investigative media articles by eTN and WorldTourismWire related to the UNWTO Secretary General election, threatening with legal action.

Rifai introduced Ambassador  Zurab Pololikashvili the widely criticized Ambassador from Georgia, who is the nominee for the Secretary General post to the attending ambassadors and embassy officials attending from 90 countries  There was a chance for Mr. Pololikashvili to say something – but he kept silence staring on this I-phone most of the time.
While remarkably, Taleb failed to address documented election misconduct within his own organization. Which in reality is OUR organization. UNWTO belongs to the global tourism industry and its continued slide into opaqueness, rather than transparency, is disturbing.
Walter Mzembi from Zimbabwe mounted a robust campaign to have agenda items related to election irregularities added to the General Assembly meeting in China next month. This has received a great deal of pushback from Secretary General Rifai.

Mzembi provided UNWTO with irrefutable documentation of irregularities during the election, and one would have hoped the outgoing Secretary General would be proactive, to shine a light on it, to make it right.

The top post of our UNWTO should be our top watch dog, guarding fiercely the reputation, standards, and ethics of the world’s leading tourism organization. This does not appear to be the case with Dr. Rifai.

Attending Zimbabwe’s Ambassador Rudo Chitiga said her countries intervention is not for the good of her minister, but for the good of tourism and UNWTO.

  • Click here to download the PDF letter by the Zimbabwe Ministry of Tourism outlying the flawed election process.
  • Click here to download the PDF letter by the ZImbabwe Ministry of Tourism outlying the change proposed for the UNWTO Rules of procedure

eTN, the industry leader of global travel/tourism news, has a subsidiary media platform geared towards news relevant to UNWTO, WTTC and other major international tourism association – WorldTourismWire.

Publisher Juergen Steinmetz said: ” We report with balance and fairness, regardless of the subject within either platform. The news is news, and we have been diligently following and reporting on the UNWTO Secretary General Election, without favor, prejudice or any regard for who we might offend.”

Today, we received reports from the packed Madrid meeting, that not one single mention was made of election irregularities. We are disappointed Dr. Rifai spent time in this important meeting maligning media. As media, we have a very real obligation to report known misconduct or irregularities related to the UNWTO Secretary General election.

We are of the belief authentic efforts should be spent on reviewing and discussing miscreant conduct related to the UNWTO Secretary General election, rather than speaking poorly of media who report on the election.

So far eTN and WorldTourismWire only heard from H.E. Walter Mzembi. Some readers may think this publication is a spokesperson for Mzembi and Zimbabwe.

“Nothing could be further from the truth”,  Steinmetz continued to say.” Our floor was always open for comments. Especially we would welcome input from SG nominee Zurab Pololikashvil, and former SG candidates  Mr. Márcio Favilla, Mr. Jaime Alberto Cabal Sanclement, Mrs. Young-shim Dho.”

We will continue to report on this important story, despite pressure from the highest level our UNWTO not to.
by Mel Webster
Ministers & CEO

UNHCR’s Goodwill Ambassador, Praya Lundberg, meets with Prime Minister General Prayuth Chan-ocha

BANGKOK – Praya Lundberg, UNHCR’s Goodwill Ambassador, met with Thailand’s Prime Minister General Prayuth Chan-ocha at the Government House of Thailand. This meeting is the first of its kind since Praya’s appointment as Goodwill Ambassador in January 2017. During the meeting, Praya expressed her gratitude to the Royal Thai Government for generously hosting refugees for over three decades.

News

UNWTO Aug 25 meeting in Madrid will have surprise guests

As reported by WorldTourismWire the UNWTO Secretary General called for a meeting of Madrid based ambassadors on August 25  to discuss the General Assembly. Most certainly Zimbabwe’s concern about flaws in the election process of the nominated Secretary General Zurab Pololikashvili should be a major issue for debate.

It appears WorldTourismWire reports encouraged Ambassador Rudo Chitiga from Zimbabwe to travel to Madrid as well. She is Zimbabwe’s ambassador based in Paris, France. Spain and UNWTO is also part of her responsibility. Most likely she will be facing Ambassador from Georgia and nominee Zurab  Pololikashvili.

Ambassador Chitiga was the spokesperson of the Zimbabwe campaign team and said  in May the country and the continent was devastated by the election outcome.

At the same time, reliable sources told WorldTourismWire Ambassador Dho Young-shim is on a plane traveling from Seoul to Madrid planning to attend this meeting as well. Dho was a candidate in the election and walked away third place. So far she has been quiet about the election issue and the concerns raised by her fellow candidate HE Dr. Walter Mzembi, Minister of Tourism and Hospitality for Zimbabwe.

Georgia, Zimbabwe, South Korea and the Madrid based diplomatic community is in for an exciting meeting tomorrow, hopefully opening the floor for a solution to this election crisis the organization is facing at the upcoming assembly in Chengdu, China.

UNWTO meeting to discuss General Assembly with Zurab but without Mzembi

 

Opinion

The UNWTO Election Fiasco Continues

Is the UNWTO blocking Walter Mzembi’s proposal for agenda items on widespread Secretary-General election irregularities to be presented to the full General Assembly next month in Chengdu, China?

It appears that may well be the very unfortunate case.

In recent days, the UNWTO disingenuously proposed to put Zimbabwe’s agenda items to the Executive Council, instead of the General Assembly.

The fiasco continues. The Executive Council of the UNWTO, who appear to have some culpability with election irregularities, are being asked to review and report if there were irregularities related to Georgia candidate, Zurib Polokashvili, being nominated by the Executive Council as Secretary General elect.

Despite urging global tourism leaders from backing Zimbabwe’s Walter Mzembi proposal to have the General Assembly review and address the agenda items, the UNWTO continues to bring the organization into disrepute.  Transparency, vigilance and authentic efforts to review documented instances of election misconduct is vital for the future of our UNWTO.  This should not be turned over individuals who may have a vested interest in concealing miscreant election activity. This starts with the decision of whether to table the Mzembi agenda items to the General Assembly.

The Mzembi agenda items absolutely must be put forth to the General Assembly, too much is at stake to conceal the election misconduct. Enough of the backroom meetings, the deals, the secret handshakes.

By shining light on election wrong-doings, the UNWTO will be taking a very important step forward to rehabilitating what has become in recent months, a rather tarnished reputation.

Pololikashvili’s nomination requires two-thirds of all member countries attending the September General Assembly to vote for the Georgia candidate before he is ratified to lead our UNWTO.  This is not a foregone conclusion. This should not be a done deal.  With access to Mzembi agenda items that fully detail election irregularities related to the Pololikashvili’s candidacy, campaign and subsequent nomination to Secretary General Elect, the General Assembly can only then vote intelligently. The Mzembi agenda items must not be dismissed or marginalized.  The Mzembi agenda items must be made available to all voting members so the sham nomination of Zurab Pololikashvili, elect can possibly be corrected in Chengdu, China by the General Assembly.

This is global tourism’s top post. Perhaps not surprisingly, the election process has shown us we are not immune to misconduct at the highest levels of what has been globally known as an unimpeachable organization with integrity and dignity.  This is our UNWTO, we expect better, we demand better, we deserve better.

by Mel Webster

Opinion

UNWTO wants Executive Council to respond to Mzembi’s agenda item request

The days are counting down to the UNWTO General Assembly in Chengdu.  The games in implementing procedural bureaucracy to an essential issue, the alleged flaws in the election of a new Secretary General is in full swing.  Zurab Pololikashvili is avoiding a response to media requests or any request to get his side of the story into the open.

WorldTourismWire asked UNWTO: The Hon. Walter Mzembi asked for agenda points to be added to the General Assembly program in regards to the SG Election. Was this approved?

UNWTO responded: In accordance with UNWTO rules and regulations, the request by the Government of Zimbabwe to add new items to the Agenda of the upcoming UNWTO GA has been communicated to all UNWTO Members States by Note Verbal. The decision on whether or not to include new items in the Agenda is the sole responsibility of the General Assembly which will decide upon this request when the item “Adoption of the agenda” is discussed.

In a bizarre move, it appears UNWTO is trying to push the concern by Zimbabwe on “flaws” in the election process back to the “defendant” the Executive Council

The same Executive Council accused of irregularities by the Hon. Mzembi is meeting before the start of the UNWTO General Assembly on September 12.

The intention by Zimbabwe was to have the full assembly review the issue, but it appears the secretariat is throwing the ball first to the Executive Council. http://lmd.unwto.org/event/executive-council-106th-session-0

The UNWTO Secretariat did not add any agenda items but is asking the same Executive Council  and informed:

Consequently, and since the statements and alleged irregularities mainly refer to the Executive Council, the Council is requested to report on this matter to the 22nd session of the General Assembly, in order to provide the Assembly with all the necessary information when considering the proposal submitted by Zimbabwe.

UNWTO issued the following document:
Click here to read